about us | newsletter | contact | archive | members area
TEODOR TARLE, BEARINGPOINT
Regulatory tsunamis, internationalization and technological changes are the elements tha»
  Features:      EDITORIAL   |   COUNTRY FOCUS   |   DECISION MAKERS   |   SECTOR ANALYSIS   |   BUSINESS LEADERS   |   EXPERTS PLATFORM   |

Tackling a taxing problem

Doubling the penalties for tax evasion – this was a measure suggested in an amendment to a law put forward by Senate vice-president, Dan Voiculescu. The amendment was not supported by his colleagues, prompting Voiculescu to resign. So where does Romania stand on tax evasion?

July 2012 - From the Print Edition

In previous years, local tax evasion reached more than 10 percent of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), meaning EUR 10 billion in absolute value.
Much tax evasion comes from the black labor market. Employers fail to report approximately 35 percent of the employees registered in the national accounts to the state’s registries. This means that over two million jobs are unofficial, almost half the total number of pensioners. Other major sources are unpaid VAT and income tax.
A report by the Fiscal Council for last year claimed that if Romania fully collected all the taxes and charges that were payable, it could have record budgetary revenues – as a percentage of GDP – close to the EU average. This suggests a complete rethinking of how to collect taxes in Romania is called for. The state should pursue tax dodgers, not try to get even more out of those who currently pay, as our politicians seem to favor. In other words, it’s not increase existing revenue streams that should be the target, but getting the evaders to start paying up.
A few years ago there was a buzz about the idea of a wealth tax. Many of us have encountered enterprising individuals whose official income seems unable to support their lavish lifestyle, and yet there is no obvious source for their additional earnings. Such a tax ought not to be punitive, but should encourage all categories of citizens to participate in achieving the GDP.
Unfortunately, the idea did not get beyond the discussion stage in Romania, though it has been successfully applied in Europe. For example in Germany, a solidarity tax of 5.5 percent is levied on income tax for higher earners. Very large estates are taxed in other countries, such as France, Switzerland and Norway. It is clear that such a law must be very well designed, as it must not simply hammer the wealthy. The law should be crafted so it catches almost all taxpayers who own property and who can really afford to pay tax but avoid doing it.
Recently, a ranking of the prices in Romania compared to EU prices was released. In some categories Romania has the lowest prices in the EU, and these include alcohol and tobacco. The thought occurred to me: why don’t we apply – even if just temporarily – an additional tax (let’s name it for solidarity) on these types of products?
But the issue would still probably be the state’s capacity to collect. The government must therefore find a way to persuade tax evaders to go legit. Everyone knows that some of the more persistent offenders will need a hard line to be taken. Specifically, in Romania’s case, strong sanctions for tax evasion – doubling the current punishments should work.
Which brings us back to the recent goings-on in Parliament. I won’t get bogged down in the detail of who came up with the amendment and the reason for the resignation. But I wonder why MPs rejected it. Do they have a vested interest in continuing to protect those who cause the biggest holes in the budget through tax evasion? Whether or not we get an answer to this question, unfortunately the problem remains, and given the parlous state of Romania’s finances a solution is becoming increasingly necessary.



COMMENTS
There are 2 comments:

VICHI: on 2012-07-17 09:52:20
Voiculescu also advanced in several times the ideea of dropping VAT for basic food, but the Governement, leaded until spring, by Boc and Basescu, disagreed.

Limon: on 2012-07-17 11:27:01
@Vichi, this is a very good idea, and a ''must'' for Victor Ponta.

 
ADD A COMMENT
 
Name
Email
Comment
Validation Code
   
 
 

2 Comments  |  5235 Views
Daily Info
Ratio between pensioners and employees could double by 2032 as compared to 2014, pension fund manager says

The ratio between pensioners and employees could double by 2032 as compared to 2014, which will cause problems in covering the necessary pension payments by the employees for ...

Damages to electricity networks caused by severe weather conditions do not increase the distribution tariffs, says ACUE

Lately, Romania confronted with extreme, unpredictable meteorological phenomena that have caused major damages, in large areas, to electricity distribution networks.

Orbis turnover increased to 62 million Euro in Q1

The Orbis Hotel Group turnover increased by 4.4 million Euro in Q1 2017 up to 62 million Euro, a press release shows. Group's EBITDA in the first quarter totalled 8.9 millio...

Deloitte Romania appoints Alexandru Reff as new country managing partner

Alexandru Reff has been appointed country managing partner Deloitte Romania and Moldova, effective June 1, 2017. He will succeed Ahmed Hassan, who takes on a regional leadersh...

Cushman & Wakefield Echinox expands its retail department with new appointment

Cushman & Wakefield Echinox consolidates its retail team by recruiting Dana Radoveneanu, a specialist with six years of experience of the local retail market, a press release ...

 
 
   
advertising

advertising

advertising

advertising

More on Features
Retailers to continue their expansion this year on the local market

Retailers will continue their expansion plans in 2017, possibly with a larger number of store openings than 2016. Consumption will continue to grow and new laws that come i...

Sergiu Oprescu, ARB: We need to rebuild trust between banks

Trust between Romanian banks must be rebuilt, according to Sergiu Oprescu, Chairman of the Board of the Romanian Banking Association (ARB). He said the banking system in 20...

Automotive industry still has room for growth, but at a slower pace?

The past few decades have witnessed the automotive industry gaining significantly from the globalization opportunity. Having established a footprint across most major marke...

Romania on the road to become Emerging Capital Market

Romania is set to attract billions of Euro once upgraded to an Emerging Market - a status which will allow the economy to benefit from massive capital inflows, concluded re...

G4S

Raluca Florentina Dumitriu, General Manager of G4S Secure Solutions Romania

Romelectro Goes Global!

Romelectro is one of the most important EPC contractors in Romania for complex projects in the energy field. The company has over 45 years of experience in the field. It st...

Romania: Every market has a silver lining

Authorities should continue to adjust their models of economic growth and put more emphasis on the absorption of EU funds and infrastructure development, according to the p...